When we re-entered the courtroom, the atmosphere had transformed from tense uncertainty into the suffocating chill of a sentencing hearing.
Julian Vance was no longer sitting at the counsel table. He was seated two rows back in the spectator pews, his briefcase closed and resting between his feet. A senior partner from his firm, an older, silver-haired man named Richard Sterling whom I recognized from local news broadcasts, was now standing at the defense table.
Sterling looked as if he had just swallowed a bottle of vinegar. He didn't look at my father, nor did he offer Margaret a chair as she stumbled back to her seat.
Judge Simmons entered, took his seat, and didn't bother opening his binder. He placed his hands flat on the desk, staring down at my father with the cold, unyielding scrutiny of an executioner.
"Let the record reflect," Judge Simmons began, "that Mr. Julian Vance has been relieved as counsel of record. Mr. Richard Sterling has made a limited appearance on behalf of Vance & Sterling LLP to address the matter of the fraudulent exhibits."
Sterling cleared his throat, stepping forward. "Your Honor, on behalf of the partnership, I wish to formally withdraw Exhibits One through Four submitted by our former associate. A preliminary internal review conducted during the recess reveals that the purported tax receipts provided by Mr. Robert Carter were, in fact, scanned duplicates altered using digital image-editing software. The serial numbers match invoices printed by an office supply store in Chesapeake three weeks ago."
My father let out a soft, defeated groan, his head sinking into his hands.
"Furthermore," Sterling continued, his voice crisp and completely devoid of warmth, "our firm is tendering an immediate and unconditional motion for voluntary dismissal with prejudice. We offer our deepest apologies to Master Chief Carter and to this court for the profound failure of due diligence."
"Your apology is noted, Mr. Sterling," Judge Simmons said sternly. "However, the matter of professional disciplinary referrals will be handled separately by the Virginia State Bar. Right now, we have the matter of criminal conduct committed inside this courtroom."
Judge Simmons looked down at Robert.
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
"Robert Carter, stand up."
Robert didn't move. Margaret had to nudge him, her fingers digging into his shoulder, before he slowly, weakly dragged himself to his feet. The swagger was gone. The polished banker was gone. All that remained was a hollow, terrified old man whose house of cards had finally collapsed.
"Mr. Carter," Judge Simmons said, his voice echoing like rolling thunder, "you have committed perjury under oath. You have submitted forged instruments to a court of record. And you have attempted to use the judicial power of the Commonwealth of Virginia to perpetrate a grand larceny valued in excess of two million dollars against your own flesh and blood."
"Your Honor... please," Robert choked out, his throat working convulsively. "I... I was desperate. The investments... our home..."
"I do not care about your investments, Mr. Carter," Judge Simmons cut him off mercilessly. "Men and women wearing the uniform your daughter wears are currently standing watch in the Persian Gulf, patrolling the South China Sea, and bleeding in hospitals so that people like you can sit in comfortable mansions and complain about your stock portfolios. For you to stand in this courtroom and attempt to steal from a wounded veteran while using her honorable service as an accusation of abandonment is among the most despicable things I have witnessed in forty-two years of legal practice."
Judge Simmons picked up his pen and signed the order resting before him with a sharp, scratching flourish.
"The plaintiff’s petition for quiet title is hereby DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE," the judge ruled. "Title to Carter Ridge Farm is affirmed as sole, absolute, and unencumbered property of Master Chief Evelyn Carter."
Judge Simmons paused, picking up a second document.
"Furthermore, pursuant to the testamentary trust of Arthur Carter, this court finds that the plaintiffs’ legal action has triggered the immediate acceleration of the promissory note dated June 12th, 1998. Judgment is entered against Robert and Margaret Carter, jointly and severally, in the amount of five hundred and eighty-four thousand, two hundred and twelve dollars, plus statutory interest."
Margaret let out a low, animal wail, collapsing forward against the mahogany table.
May you like
001 My Husband Crashed Our Son’s Wedding Wearing My Vintage Gown—When He...
30/10B7 My Father Gave My Graduation VIP Pass To My Stepsister And Pushe...
30/10B37 My Family Invited My Cheating Wife To Thanksgiving And Told Me...
"And finally," Judge Simmons continued, his gaze shifting to the back of the room where two Portsmouth police officers had just quietly entered and stood flanking the exit, "this court refers the matter of forged public documents and aggravated perjury to the Commonwealth's Attorney for immediate grand jury indictment. Deputy Miller, take Mr. Robert Carter into custody."
***