Dawn broke over the Roaring Fork Valley in a magnificent blaze of rose-gold and icy blue. The storm had passed, leaving behind fourteen inches of pristine, untouched powder that clung to the boughs of the Douglas firs like spun sugar.
In the Pitkin County Sheriff’s substation in downtown Aspen, the atmosphere was considerably less picturesque.
Arthur Montgomery sat on a metal bench in the processing area, his camel-hair coat stained with road grime, his silk tie crooked, his eyes wild and bloodshot. Beside him, Brenda was wrapped in a scratchy county-issued wool blanket, sniffling uncontrollably while their younger daughter, Megan, sat in a plastic chair staring at the linoleum floor in shell-shocked silence.
In the corner cell, Kyle was shivering beneath two blankets, his right foot wrapped in medical bandages for first-degree frostbite.
The heavy glass doors of the station opened, and Evelyn Carter walked in.
She was accompanied by Jonathan Hayes and two junior associates carrying thick briefcases. Evelyn wore an impeccably tailored wool suit in deep forest green, her posture straight as an arrow, commanding the room the instant her heels touched the floor.
Sheriff Campbell stepped out from behind the counter, holding a steaming mug of coffee. "Morning, Evelyn. Sorry to drag you down here after a long flight, but the District Attorney wanted you to review the final charge sheet before we transfer them to the county jail in Eagle."
Arthur jumped to his feet, rattling the bench. "Evelyn! You have to drop these charges! Look at us! We've been treated like animals! They made Brenda take off her jewelry! They put my nephew in a cell with common drunks!"
Evelyn stopped three feet from the bench. She looked down at Arthur Montgomery with an expression of such total, withering detachment that the man’s voice trailed off into an insecure whimper.
"You are not being treated like animals, Arthur," Evelyn said. "You are being treated like common thieves. Which is precisely what you are."
Brenda looked up from her blanket, her mascara running down her wrinkled cheeks. "Evelyn, please... we made a mistake! We were desperate! Arthur’s business... they were going to take our furniture! The banks took everything! We just wanted a place to start over! Claire said you had so many rooms—she said you’d never even notice if we took the west wing!"
"Claire lied to you," Evelyn said coldly. "Just as she lied to my son. But your desperation does not grant you a license to pillage my home, forge my dead husband’s trust papers, and trespass on private property with moving vans."
Jonathan Hayes stepped forward, opening his briefcase and placing three sets of bound documents on the front counter.
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
"Mr. Montgomery," Jonathan said, "I have spent the last four hours conferring with the Pitkin County District Attorney, the Los Angeles County DA, and the state attorney general’s financial crimes division. Here is the reality of your current legal position:
"You are currently facing three counts of felony criminal trespass, two counts of grand larceny for the removal of property from the Burbank vault, one count of identity theft for the unauthorized use of Daniel Carter’s corporate credit line, and one count of criminal conspiracy."
Arthur’s knees buckled. He sank back down onto the metal bench, his hands shaking violently. "No... no, that’s twenty years in prison..."
"Under standard sentencing guidelines, it would likely be twelve to fifteen," Jonathan corrected dispassionately. "However, Mrs. Carter is a woman of exceptional Christian forbearance."
Arthur looked up, a faint, desperate spark of hope flickering in his hollow eyes. "Evelyn... you’ll drop the charges?"
"I will not drop them," Evelyn stated clearly. "I will suspend them. Under three non-negotiable conditions."
She stepped closer, leaning down slightly so her voice reached only the family huddled on the bench.
"Condition one: You will sign a full confession acknowledging that you entered Pitkin County without permission, that Daniel Carter had no legal authority to grant you access, and that the items removed from the Burbank vault were stolen. That confession will remain in Jonathan Hayes’s safe. If any member of the Montgomery family ever contacts Daniel, myself, or approaches within five hundred yards of any Carter property again, that confession will be submitted to the court within twenty minutes."
"We’ll sign it," Arthur choked out, nod-ding furiously. "We’ll sign it right now."
"Condition two," Evelyn continued, her voice hardening. "You will surrender all rights, claims, and counterclaims regarding the wedding, the marriage, and any financial support from Daniel Carter. Your daughter Claire will execute the annulment agreement without contest. She will receive zero dollars in spousal support, zero dollars in legal fees, and she will personally return the five-carat engagement ring Daniel gave her within twenty-four hours."
Brenda gasped. "That ring is worth eighty thousand dollars! She can't—"
"Condition three," Evelyn cut her off, her eyes flashing like steel. "You will take your moving vans—which Marcus Vance will allow you to retrieve under armed escort—and you will leave the state of Colorado before noon. If I see those trucks on Maroon Creek Road after twelve o'clock, Deputy Miller has standing orders to arrest every single one of you, including your asthmatic daughter, and book you into the state penitentiary."
Evelyn straightened her coat and turned toward the door.
"You have ten minutes to decide, Arthur. Either you sign the papers and live as bankrupt outcasts in California, or you spend the next decade eating state prison food. The choice is entirely yours."
May you like
001 My Husband Crashed Our Son’s Wedding Wearing My Vintage Gown—When He...
30/10B7 My Father Gave My Graduation VIP Pass To My Stepsister And Pushe...
30/10B37 My Family Invited My Cheating Wife To Thanksgiving And Told Me...
She walked toward the exit without waiting for an answer. Behind her, the frantic sound of pens scribbling across legal paper told her everything she needed to know.
***