All storiesChapter 1 of 2

29-10-B44 My Stepmother Stripped Me of My Halloween Costume to Hand It to Her Golden Daughter—Ten Years Later, They Showed Up Begging at My Door

Chapter 1 - The Girl Under the Scoreboard

6 min readYour place is saved automatically

The gym smelled of damp gym socks, burnt sugar, and apple cider punch. The gym floor had been covered with cheap gray tarps to protect the basketball varnish, and every time someone walked past, the plastic crackled like static electricity. Streamers of orange and black crepe paper hung in limp loops from the rafters, twisting under the industrial ceiling fans.

Ava was already the center of the gym.

She stood near the DJ booth, where Mr. Henderson, the eighth-grade history teacher, was fiddling with an iPod plugged into two towering speakers. A crowd of girls had gathered around her, their faces painted as cats, vampires, and pop stars. They were reaching out to touch the soft, layered violet tulle of the skirt—the exact hemline I had swept three coats of clear fabric sealer onto so the silver threads wouldn’t fray.

"Ava, where did you even find this?" asked Taylor Simmons, whose mother owned the boutique downtown. "The layers are so full! Did your mom order it from that vintage catalog?"

Ava’s smile was fragile at first, her gaze darting toward the double doors as if she expected someone to blow a whistle and call a foul. But no whistle blew. The admiration was loud, immediate, and warm. She adjusted the brim of the crooked hat—my hat, with the cardboard moon I had shaped using a compass from my fifth-grade geometry set—and dipped her chin.

"My mom helped me put it together," Ava said. The words came out smooth, like butter spread over warm toast. "We worked really hard on it."

Standing forty feet away beneath the giant, red digital scoreboard, my back pressed against the cold cinderblock wall, I felt the air leave my lungs in a slow, icy hiss.

"Did she really just say that?" Chloe hissed beside me. Chloe was dressed as Amelia Earhart, complete with leather aviator goggles pushed up into her messy blonde hair and a silk scarf tied around her neck. Her fists were shoved so deep into her bomber jacket pockets that the brown leather stretched tight. "Lily, I literally took a picture of you in your bedroom two weeks ago with the receipt sitting on your nightstand. Tell Mr. Henderson."

"What’s Mr. Henderson going to do?" I asked, my voice barely audible over the opening bassline of "Thriller." "Disqualify her from walking around in circles?"

"He’s running the costume contest at five!" Chloe said, her face flushing red. "There’s a fifty-dollar Visa gift card and a giant pumpkin bucket full of candy. You paid sixty-five dollars for that dress! With your own chores! You cleaned your dad’s disgusting oil stains off the driveway!"

"It doesn't matter," I whispered. But my throat burned with that awful, stinging tightness that comes before crying. I clamped my teeth together until my jaw ached.

I was wearing a faded gray T-shirt with the logo of a 5K race my dad had run three years ago, dark blue denim jeans that had already grown an inch too short at the ankles, and my beaten-up white sneakers with grass stains on the toes. Everyone else looked like a fantasy. Madison was an elaborate mermaid with turquoise scales painted across her cheekbones. Paige was an 80s rock star with teased hair and neon leg warmers.

And I looked like I had gotten lost on my way to the grocery store.

Ava didn't look at me once for the first half-hour. She danced in a circle with the girls from the track team. When the skirt spun out, catching the gym's fluorescent lights, the silver stitching looked like tiny shooting stars. I knew how it felt to spin in that skirt; I had done it three times in my bedroom before Ava knocked on my door. It was light as a cloud and made a gentle, whispering sound against your knees.

At four-forty-five, Mr. Henderson tapped the microphone. A high-pitched squeal ripped through the gymnasium, and fifty middle schoolers covered their ears.

"All right, goblins and ghouls!" Mr. Henderson shouted cheerfully. "Line up by grade along the south bleachers for the costume judging! Remember, our PTA volunteers will be voting on Most Creative, Scariest, and Best Overall!"

"Lily, go stand in line," Chloe urged, grabbing my elbow. "Just go up there and stand next to her. Let people see."

"See what, Chloe? That I don't have a costume?"

"You had one! Tell everyone she took it!"

"My dad told me to give it to her," I said, and saying it out loud made a strange, cold numbness settle into my chest. "He was standing right there. He looked at me, and he told me I was selfish."

Chloe’s hand slipped off my sleeve. Her blue eyes were wide with a fierce, helpless pity that hurt worse than Karen’s smug look when she took the dress from my hands. "Your dad is an idiot," she muttered, her voice trembling. "A total, absolute idiot."

Ava won Best Overall.

When Mr. Henderson called her name—"Ava Mitchell, our enchanting twilight witch!"—the entire gym cheered. Ava walked up to the small folding table in front of the bleachers, her cheeks bright pink. Karen was standing near the gym entrance by then; she had come early to pick us up, wearing her expensive camel-hair trench coat and holding her iPhone high in the air to record a video.

Karen caught my eye over the heads of twenty cheering kids. Her expression didn't flicker with guilt or hesitation. She offered me a curt, tight nod—the kind of nod a teacher gives a student who finally followed directions—before turning her phone back toward Ava.

Ava held up the plastic trophy and the fifty-dollar gift card. The purple tulle fell around her ankles in graceful folds.

When the party ended, we walked out into the cool Texas evening. The sun had set, leaving a bruised-purple sky over the parking lot that matched the color of my stolen skirt.

Dad was waiting by the front passenger door of his silver sedan, his hands tucked into his fleece vest. When he saw Ava walking out with the trophy, his face broke into a broad, relieved smile.

"Look at you!" he said, pulling Ava into a one-armed hug. "Best Overall! Karen texted me from inside."

"She won a gift card, Mark!" Karen said, bustling up behind us, her cheeks flushed with triumph. "Everyone was asking where we bought the materials. I told them it was a custom piece."

I stood on the curb, the cool breeze biting through my thin gray shirt.

Dad finally looked at me. His smile dimmed just a fraction, the corners of his mouth twitching with an uncomfortable awareness. But then his eyes hardened, putting up that familiar wall of adult authority that meant he didn't want to be made to feel guilty.

"Did you have fun, Lily?" he asked, his tone clipped, daring me to complain.

"The punch was okay," I said evenly.

Ava looked at the ground, clutching the plastic trophy against her chest. The cardboard moon I had drawn was beginning to curl at the edges from the damp air.

"Get in the car, girls," Dad said, unlocking the doors with a chirping beep. "We're going to order pizza to celebrate."

May you like

001 My Husband Crashed Our Son’s Wedding Wearing My Vintage Gown—When He Opened His Envelope, the Bride Turned White as a Ghost

001 My Husband Crashed Our Son’s Wedding Wearing My Vintage Gown—When He...

30/10B7 My Father Gave My Graduation VIP Pass To My Stepsister And Pushed Me Into The Rain, Unaware The 4-Star General Delayed The Ceremony For Me

30/10B7 My Father Gave My Graduation VIP Pass To My Stepsister And Pushe...

30/10B37 My Family Invited My Cheating Wife To Thanksgiving And Told Me To "Stay Neutral" — So I Left And Ruined All Of Them

30/10B37 My Family Invited My Cheating Wife To Thanksgiving And Told Me...

I climbed into the back seat, pressing myself against the cold glass of the window. Beside me, the purple tulle pooled across the upholstery, brushing against my denim jeans. I didn't touch it. I didn't say a single word all the way home.

***

Up next: Chapter 2 - The Receipt in the Drawer

Chapters

  1. 1Chapter 1 - The Girl Under the Scoreboard
  2. 2Chapter 2 - The Receipt in the Drawer