Karen’s Facebook post went live at eight-thirty that night, while the smell of delivery pizza was still hanging in our kitchen.
I was sitting at the small built-in desk in the corner of my bedroom, trying to focus on my pre-algebra homework, when my phone buzzed on the blotter. It was a screenshot from Chloe.
Below the screenshot, Chloe had typed four question marks and an angry-face emoji.
I opened the image. Karen had posted three photos. The first was Ava on the gym bleachers, holding the plastic trophy high with both hands, the violet tulle billowing around her knees. The second was a close-up of the silver embroidery on the collar. The third was a photo of Karen and Ava hugging on the front porch before we left for the school.
The caption read:
*"So incredibly proud of my girl Ava tonight! Took home 1st Place for Best Overall Costume at the Middle School Social! It took weeks of planning, hunting down fabrics, and late nights making sure every stitch was perfect, but seeing her shine like this makes every single sacrifice worth it. A true labor of love from a mother's heart! #ProudMom #DIYCostume #Winner #MyGirl"*
There were already forty-seven likes and twelve comments.
*"Karen, you are such an amazing mother! She looks like an angel!"*
*"Wow, Ava looks stunning! You have so much talent!"*
*"Parent of the year right here!"*
My fingers were trembling as I stared at the screen.
*Weeks of planning.*
*Hunting down fabrics.*
*A mother's heart.*
I opened my middle desk drawer. Beneath my colored pencils and a stack of lined notebook paper lay a faded blue metal pencil tin with cartoon strawberries painted on the lid. Inside was my spiral notebook—a seventy-page Mead notebook with a green cover.
I flipped to page three.
*August 8: Garage sweep — $5.00*
*August 15: Washed patio chairs — $5.00*
*August 22: Sorted cable box (Dad said good job) — $10.00*
*August 29: Pulled weeds by the AC unit — $5.00*
*September 5: Cleaned baseboards in hallway — $5.00*
*September 12: Allowance — $5.00*
*September 19: Allowance — $5.00*
*September 26: Washed both cars — $15.00*
Keep the story going
Watch a short ad to unlock the rest of this chapter.
*October 3: Allowance — $5.00*
*Total saved: $60.00 + $5.00 birthday money from Grandma = $65.00.*
Taped beneath the neat columns of my twelve-year-old handwriting was the thin, crinkled white slip from *Costume Castle* on South Lamar Boulevard.
*10/03/2026 14:22*
*ITEM: DLX TWILIGHT WITCH - YTH L*
*SUBTOTAL: $60.03*
*TAX: $4.97*
*TOTAL: $65.00*
*CASH: $65.00*
*CHANGE: $0.00*
I smoothed my thumb over the receipt. The ink was already faint in the corners.
There was a soft knock on my bedroom door. It swung open before I could say anything, and Ava stepped inside.
She had already changed into her flannel pajamas. Over her arm, she carried the purple dress. The silver belt was dangling loosely from the waistband, and the crooked hat was perched awkwardly under her elbow.
"Here," Ava said quietly, holding it out toward the desk. "I hung it up in my closet for an hour so it wouldn't get wrinkled, but... you can have it back now."
I didn't turn around in my chair. I looked at her reflection in the dark bedroom window. "Keep it."
"Lily, don't be weird," she said, shifting her weight from foot to foot. "The party's over. I don't need it anymore."
"I said keep it, Ava."
"Why are you acting like this? My mom said it was fine. You weren't even that mad in the car."
"I was mad," I said, my voice dropping so low she had to step closer to hear me. "I was furious. But my dad was standing right there, and he wanted you to have it more than he wanted me to have what I earned."
Ava set the costume on the edge of my bed. "Well, I'm leaving it here. It's your dress."
"It's not my dress," I said. "Your mom told fifty people online that she made it. She told everyone in the gym you stayed up late sewing it. If I wear it on Monday for trick-or-treating, everybody's going to think I stole your costume."
Ava blinked, her mouth opening slightly. "She... she just posted that on Facebook. Nobody at school is going to care about Facebook."
"Everyone's moms look at Facebook, Ava. Chloe's mom already saw it."
Ava looked down at the purple tulle resting on my floral bedspread. For a second, a flicker of genuine shame crossed her features. She reached into her pajama pocket and pulled out the fifty-dollar Visa gift card she had won.
"You can have this," she whispered, extending her hand. "Take the card. You can buy another one."
I looked at the silver card. It had a festive cartoon ghost printed on the corner. Fifty dollars. It was fifteen dollars less than the costume had cost, but it represented something far worse: hush money to make her feel less guilty about stealing my night.
"I don't want your card," I said. "Take it and leave my room."
Before Ava could answer, footsteps sounded in the hallway. Dad appeared in the doorway, a mug of coffee in his hand. He looked between Ava’s outstretched hand, the dress on the bed, and my rigid posture at the desk.
His face clouded with immediate irritation.
"What is going on in here now?" Dad demanded, walking into the room. "Ava, why are you offering her that card?"
"I was just—" Ava started, but Dad cut her off.
"Lily, are you badgering your sister for her prize?" Dad asked, his voice rising in that sharp, lecturing tone he only ever used with me. "She won that fair and square. You didn't even enter the contest."
May you like
001 My Husband Crashed Our Son’s Wedding Wearing My Vintage Gown—When He...
30/10B7 My Father Gave My Graduation VIP Pass To My Stepsister And Pushe...
30/10B37 My Family Invited My Cheating Wife To Thanksgiving And Told Me...
I felt the blood drain from my face. "I'm not badgering her! She was trying to give it to me!"
"Because you're sitting in here pouting and making her feel guilty!" Dad snapped. "Your stepmother